First, here's the ranking of the rides as determined by their median values:
1) Kingda Ka
2) Nitro
3) Superman
4) El Toro
5) Medusa
6) Batman
7) Scream Machine
8) Skull Mountain
9) Dark Knight
Next, here's the same rankings with standard deviations included, to give a sense of the variance in the votes. Note that almost all of the variance in Dark Knight's ranking came from one data point, much to Danny's chagrin. He called the perpetrator a bad name, which is unfair. Maybe he just really liked Dark Knight?
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/7d997/7d997a171f7a64bcf2c53ce8f523274021c4c573" alt=""
The variance is actually fairly low, which makes me question whether or not the rankings were entirely independent. Rob and Tyson have exactly the same rankings, which is suspicious on a number of levels.
Finally, I wanted to see why they would rank the rides in this way. I went to Great Adventure's website, and looked at some statistics from each of the rides. First, the rides are all ranked in terms of thrill levels as either "mild," "moderate," or "max." The two rides that these guys ranked lowest, Skull Mountain and Scream Machine, were both "moderate," while the rest of the rides were "max." Next, I wondered if there was a correlation between ride speed and the rankings. But for this we need another chart:
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/b5b9c/b5b9c8ee7cb589097b611ab54c3056cdf590be56" alt=""
Anyways, it seems like these Vassar students prefer fast rides to slow ones. Congrats on all graduating, too.